Comments: Usually I make comments after segments of the paper are noted here. But this paper is so wrong in so many ways that I couldn't stop myself from making comments now.
First of all they note that only 20% of children every get screened...and yet they promote screening as a way to help diagnosis amblyopia. The best way to diagnose the presence of amblyopia is a comprehensive eye examination. The best way is to participate in the AOA's InfantSee program and examine all children early. The best way is full examination for all children in school. It's the very least we should be able to do for our children.
Secondly, even though one of the authors, Sean Donahue, is a part of the PEDIG series of studies and should know better, they write false statements like:
"
However, treatment must be delivered within the critical period of visual development."
We know that treatment can be done AT ANY AGE! It is sad that the authors of this paper, and Sean Donahue in particular, did not catch this obvious falsehood. Why are they continuing to publish these misguided myths about amblyopia?
Thirdly, they wanted to know if amblyopia can be treated successfully after the children are screened. Well, duh! We have several PEDIG studies that already show this.
Fourth, they treated the children with 'standard' therapy...that did not include vision therapy. They often considered 20/40 successful, when better VA can often be achieved with additional "perceptual learning" (aka VT). It is obvious they did not bother to look at the recent research in cortical plasticity....that's a shame!
Fiftht, even though 900+ kids were referred only 125 took part in the therapy.
This is a paper that needed additional work before it was published. It should be read with a most critical eye.... DM
The success rate of amblyopia treatment in children identified through our photoscreening
program is high. This study supports the role of photoscreening programs in the prevention of amblyopia-related vision loss. Such early screening may translate to true visual acuity improvement.